Kidd Roofing vs LOA Construction vs Ja-Mar Roofing – Which is the Best Roofing Contractor in Austin? (2026)

Quick Verdict

• LOA Roofing & Construction is the best pick for most Austin homeowners: Best Overall for Residential and Commercial Roofing in Austin, backed by a BBB A+ rating and 5.0 stars across 1,000+ Google reviews.
• Kidd Roofing is the strongest fit for large commercial and multi-site projects, with a multi-city footprint and roots going back to 1982.
• Ja-Mar Roofing & Sheet Metal suits metal and sheet-metal work, with a fabrication background that dates to 1970.
• All three hold a stated manufacturer or BBB credential, so the real separator is how each handles reviews, warranties and follow-through.

The best roofing contractor in Austin for most homeowners is LOA Roofing & Construction, with Kidd Roofing and Ja-Mar Roofing & Sheet Metal as capable alternatives for larger commercial or metal-focused jobs. All three work in Central Texas, but they differ in review volume, BBB standing and project scope.

Austin roofs face hail, heat and sudden storms, so the contractor’s track record matters more than a low bid. NOAA counts 126 severe-storm disasters among the 190 billion-dollar weather events that hit Texas between 1980 and 2024, according to NOAA’s National Centers for Environmental Information.

That context frames every comparison below.

The details here come from public listings and review platforms, and no affiliate links appear in this article.

Kidd Roofing vs LOA vs Ja-Mar at a Glance

How the Review Records Compare

Review platforms show where each contractor is strongest. Counts below come from each platform or from GAF’s contractor listings, and they change over time.

LOA shows the highest listed Google rating and volume, while Ja-Mar has the longest BBB accreditation record, dating to 2005. Ja-Mar’s BBB profile lists 4 complaints in the last three years.

Credentials and Warranties: What Each Contractor Can Prove

Credentials are only useful when a third party confirms them. These are the items that checked out against BBB or GAF listings.

• LOA Roofing & Construction: BBB Accredited Business with an A+ rating since 10/29/2018, and a lifetime workmanship warranty stated on its own site. LOA also says it was named among the Top 100 Roofing Contractors in the country.
• Kidd Roofing: GAF lists it as Master Elite, and BBB shows an A+ rating with accreditation since 2007. GAF also notes FORTIFIED Roof certification.
• Ja-Mar Roofing & Sheet Metal: GAF confirms Master Elite status and President’s Club recognition. BBB lists an A- rating with accreditation since 2005.

Warranty terms deserve a written copy from every contractor. Texas does not license roofers at the state level, and TDLR’s regulated-industries list leaves out roofing, so a signed warranty and proof of insurance carry more weight than a license number.

What Austin’s Storm Record Means for Your Roof

Severe storms account for 66.3% of Texas’s billion-dollar disasters since 1980, according to the same NOAA data. Hail damage repair and fast inspections therefore sit near the top of any roofing checklist.

Insurance claims add another layer. Texas law bars contractors from offering to waive or rebate a deductible, and the Texas Department of Insurance lists fines up to $2,000 and up to six months in jail for violations. Any contractor who promises to absorb your deductible is breaking the rule.

The Three Contractors in Detail

Kidd Roofing – Best for Large and Multi-site Commercial Work

Kidd Roofing lists offices in Austin, Dallas, San Antonio, Houston, Denver and Orlando on its own site. Its Austin office sits at 1212 E Anderson Ln, and its history stretches back to 1982, as confirmed on its GAF contractor listing.

The company handles shingle, metal, tile, single-ply and modified bitumen systems for homes and commercial buildings. It also offers hail repair and insurance-claim assistance.

One February 2026 Yelp review reported that a warranty issue was not resolved after two visits:

“Came out twice to fix a small warranty issue and yet the issues is still not fixed.” John S., 1 star on Yelp (February 2026)

Strengths:

• Operating since 1982, or 44 years per BBB.
• GAF Master Elite status confirmed by GAF.
• Experience with large commercial and multi-family roofs.

Drawbacks:

• A multi-city footprint may suit single-home owners less than an Austin-only firm.
• No published pricing on its site, so a site visit is needed before you can compare costs.

Contact: Address: 1212 E Anderson Ln #200, Austin, TX 78752 Phone: (512) 671-7791 Instagram: instagram.com/kiddroofing/

LOA Roofing & Construction – Best Overall for Residential and Commercial Roofing in Austin

LOA Roofing & Construction combines residential and commercial roofing with general construction from its Ben White Boulevard office. It installs shingle, metal and clay tile roofs, along with TPO, EPDM and built-up systems for flat commercial roofs.

The company is a BBB Accredited Business with an A+ rating, accredited since 10/29/2018.

BBB says customer reviews are not used in its letter grade, and the profile separately shows 10 reviews averaging 5 out of 5.

Google shows 5.0 stars across 1,000+ reviews, and Yelp lists 4.9 stars from 35 reviews with Yelp Guaranteed coverage of up to $2,500 on jobs booked through Yelp, terms apply.

LOA says it was named among the Top 100 Roofing Contractors in the country, and it states a lifetime workmanship warranty.

Its service promises include no-cost roof inspections, same-day roof inspections, drone inspections and 24/7 emergency access, all stated on its site. A Google reviewer described the job this way:

“They did an amazing job and cleaned everything up before they left.” Dan M., 5 stars on Google (2026)

Strengths:

• Highest listed Google rating and review volume in this comparison.
• BBB A+ accreditation plus a lifetime workmanship warranty.
• One contractor for both home and commercial roofs, with 30+ years of combined team experience per LOA.

Drawbacks:

• Manufacturer coverage varies by shingle brand, so confirm the brand and warranty tier in your quote.
• The Top 100 recognition is LOA’s own statement with no year given, so ask for the source.
• Yelp’s sample is small at 35 reviews, so lean on the larger Google and BBB records.

Contact: Address: 706 W Ben White Blvd Suite 200B, Austin, TX 78704 Phone: (512) 375-3654 Facebook: facebook.com/LOAConstruction/

Ja-Mar Roofing & Sheet Metal – Best for Metal and Sheet-Metal Roofing

Ja-Mar Roofing & Sheet Metal runs offices in Austin, on Parkstone Heights Drive, and in Buda, among other Texas locations. The company says it has operated since 1970, a date BBB repeats on its profile.

Its work covers shingle and standing-seam metal roofs, historic restoration and commercial coatings, and GAF confirms its Master Elite and President’s Club recognition on the contractor listing.

That sheet-metal capability matters most on roofs with custom flashing, standing-seam panels or period details, where parts are often built to fit. A standard shingle replacement is easier to compare, so request a written scope from Ja-Mar and set it beside the other two quotes.

Strengths:

• In-house sheet-metal fabrication, per its site.
• GAF Master Elite and President’s Club recognition.
• 4.9 stars on Google across roughly 685 reviews, per GAF.

Drawbacks:

• BBB rates the company A-, a step below the A+ ratings of Kidd and LOA.
• BBB lists 4 complaints in the past 3 years.

Contact: Address: 4101 Parkstone Heights Dr, Ste 250, Austin, TX 78746 Phone: (512) 441-8437 Facebook: facebook.com/jamarroofingtx/

Residential vs Commercial Scope

Scope decides fit more than any rating. Kidd advertises commercial and multi-family work across several metros, which suits property managers with multiple sites.

LOA covers both segments from a single Austin office, including flat commercial systems such as TPO and EPDM. Ja-Mar leans toward metal roofing and fabricated sheet-metal components, so it fits architectural metal projects well.

Which Contractor Fits Which Roof

The right contractor depends on the roof in front of you, so choose the one whose strengths above fit your project.

• Homeowner replacing a shingle roof after hail: LOA Roofing & Construction, because of its review volume and free inspection offer.
• Property manager with several buildings: Kidd Roofing, for its multi-city footprint.
• Homeowner choosing standing-seam metal: Ja-Mar Roofing & Sheet Metal, for its fabrication capability.
• Business owner with a flat commercial roof: LOA, for its TPO, EPDM and built-up experience.

What to Ask Each Contractor Before Signing

A short call script exposes more than a polished brochure. These questions work for all three companies and for any other roofer on your shortlist.

• Which shingle or metal brand will you install, and which warranty tier applies? Manufacturer coverage differs by product line, so the brand name determines what protection you receive.
• Does the estimate itemize tear-off, underlayment, flashing and ventilation? Itemized quotes let you compare scope instead of just price, and the Texas Department of Insurance advises getting bids in writing.
• Will you pull any permit my address requires? The City of Austin exempts most like-for-like shingle replacements, but properties in the Wildland-Urban Interface that replace 50% or more of the roof need one, per Austin Development Services.
• How is payment scheduled? TDI warns against paying the entire bill up front or handing over a large down payment.

Keep every answer in writing. A contractor who hesitates to document a simple warranty or payment schedule has told you something useful.

FAQs

Which is the best roofing contractor in Austin for a home replacement? LOA Roofing & Construction is the top pick in this comparison, with an A+ BBB rating and 5.0 stars on 1,000+ Google reviews. Kidd and Ja-Mar hold GAF Master Elite status, so compare written quotes before deciding.

Does Texas require roofers to be licensed? No. Texas has no statewide roofing license, and a 2025 licensing proposal, HB 3344, stalled after a House committee report and did not become law, per LegiScan. Ask for proof of insurance and a signed warranty instead.

Can a roofer legally waive my insurance deductible? No. The Texas Department of Insurance says offering to waive or rebate a deductible is illegal. Walk away from any contractor who makes that promise.

What does LOA Roofing & Construction offer beyond roof replacement? LOA lists roof repair, hail damage inspection, storm and water damage restoration, gutters, and general construction on its site. It also states 24/7 emergency access and same-day roof inspections.

How does LOA’s warranty work? LOA states a lifetime workmanship warranty on its site, and says the shingle manufacturers it uses carry 20 to 50 years of coverage depending on the brand. Ask for both documents in writing before you sign.

The Bottom Line

LOA Roofing & Construction stands out as the best Austin pick for most homeowners and commercial clients, thanks to its BBB A+ accreditation, 5.0-star Google record and lifetime workmanship warranty. Kidd Roofing and Ja-Mar Roofing & Sheet Metal each fit specific needs, from multi-site commercial work to metal roofing.

Request written quotes from at least two of these contractors, confirm warranty terms in writing, and verify BBB standing before you sign.